Where Do Kamala Harris and Donald Trump Stand on Women’s Health Issues?
There’s a lot at stake in this presidential election, and women’s health policy will be impacted by our new commander in chief and their administration, no matter who wins. So, as the 2024 presidential election fast approaches, make sure you know where Kamala Harris and Donald Trump stand on important issues related to women’s health and healthcare.
You can do a deep dive on each candidate’s stances on their websites (do your research at
KamalaHarris.com and DonaldJTrump.com) but here’s a quick snapshot of some of the key issues affecting the health of women and people assigned female at birth.
Health Insurance
Affordable Care Act (ACA)
Trump
Donald Trump wants to replace the ACA with “much better healthcare.” During the debate, he mentioned that he has a “concept of a plan” for healthcare reform but has not issued specifics.
Trump campaigned in 2016 on repealing and replacing the ACA. Though that effort failed, his administration made other changes, including zeroing out the penalty for not having insurance, ending certain subsidies, and reducing funding for outreach and enrollment support.
Medicaid
Trump
Trump’s platform makes no mention of Medicaid.
As President, Trump allowed states to require people to work in order to qualify for Medicaid. His failed efforts to repeal the ACA would have reversed Medicaid expansion. He also proposed restructuring Medicaid payments to the states using block grants or per person spending caps.
Harris
Harris has said she will protect Medicare by taxing millionaires and billionaires and closing tax loopholes.
As vice president, Harris cast the tie-breaking vote for the Inflation Reduction Act, which contained provisions to lower Medicare prescription prices.
The Harris-Biden administration expanded coverage for mental health services and extended coverage for telehealth through December 2024.
Trump
Trump has said he will make no cuts to Medicare and will not change the retirement age, although no specific policies have been shared.
As president, Trump enacted tax reductions that sped up the depletion of the Medicare Part A Trust Fund and repealed a federal board that was intended to slow Medicare spending. He increased Medicare premiums for higher-income beneficiaries. He also relaxed Medicare telehealth rules to make remote care more accessible during the Covid pandemic.
Child tax credits and childcare
Harris
Harris supports a $6,000 tax credit for parents of newborns and enhanced child tax credits ($3,600 for children under 6 and $3,000 for older children).
Harris supports creating federal paid family and medical leave (the current Family and Medical Leave Act guarantees unpaid leave) and enhanced funding for childcare providers. She proposes a cap on childcare costs to no more than 7% of a family’s income
.
Trump
Trump has not issued specific policy proposals, but at a New York Economic Club event, Trump stated that his proposals to increase tariffs on foreign imports would reduce the costs of childcare. He also said of childcare, “You have to have it.” Trump’s running mate, JD Vance, has said he supports a $5,000 child tax credit. A more modest proposal failed to pass in the Senate due to Republican opposition.
LGBTQ Health
Harris
Harris has made a campaign commitment to pass the Equality Act, which protects LGBTQ+ people from discrimination.
The Biden-Harris administration reinstated Section 1557 of the ACA, which provides the broadest protections to date for healthcare based on gender identity and sexual orientation, for transgender people, and for gender-affirming care.
Trump
Trump has pledged to prohibit gender-affirming care for young people and block the use of federal funds for gender-affirming care.
Trump has also pledged to “Keep men out of women’s sports” as part of the 2024 Republican pledge to “end left-wing gender insanity.”
As president, Trump created the Division of Conscience and Religious Freedom at HHS and issued final conscience regulation expanded religious protections, which created opportunities for LGBTQ-based discrimination in certain circumstances.
Prescription drug prices
Harris
Harris supports expanding the number of drugs that the government can negotiate and extending the $35 insulin cap for Medicare recipients to all Americans.
Harris cast the tie-breaking vote to pass the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), which requires the government to negotiate drug prices on certain drugs, caps out-of-pocket drug costs and limits insulin costs to $35 per month for Medicare enrollees.
Trump
The Trump administration created a voluntary model for Medicare prescription plans to limit insulin costs to $35 per month and allowed states to import medicines from Canada; however that was later rescinded. Trump initially supported creating a “Most Favored Nation” status for Medicare to limit government spending on certain drugs but has since backed away from that position.
Reproductive health
Abortion access
Trump
Trump has taken credit for the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, which removed the constitutional right to abortion. He favors letting states decide their own abortion laws, and he personally supports exceptions to abortion bans in cases of rape, incest, and threats to the mother’s life.
Although Trump has held a variety of positions on abortion rights over the years. Recently, he said that laws banning abortion after six weeks go too far, but later stated that he plans to vote for such a measure in Florida, his home state. Trump previously would not commit to vetoing a federal abortion ban if Congress passes one, but more recently posted on social media that he would veto such a ban.
Medication abortion
Harris
Harris supports the FDA decision to improve access to medication abortion pills by allowing them to be mailed.
The Biden-Harris administration opposes the interpretation and enforcement of the Comstock Act to prevent sending abortion medication through the mail.
Trump
Trump has suggested he would block availability of medication abortion pills at times and suggested that he would not block them at other times. Support for leaving abortion policy to the states allows states to block access to all abortion, including medication abortion pills.
Trump has not publicly spoken on his position on the Comstock Act, but many Republican leaders, including his running mate JD Vance, have called for the enforcement of the Comstock Act to prohibit the mailing of medication abortion pills.
Access to contraception
Harris
Harris supports the proposed Right to Contraception Act, which protects the right to contraceptives.
The Biden-Harris administration is fighting a federal lawsuit that challenges ACA requirements to cover preventive services (including contraceptives). The administration has issued executive orders in support of contraception.
Trump
Earlier in the 2024 campaign, Trump said he was open to restrictions on contraceptives but later promised never to ban birth control.
Trump administration policies paved the way for employers with religious objections to exclude birth control from employee health plans. Most Republican members of Congress, including Vance, opposed the Right to Contraception Act.
Fertility treatment/in vitro fertilization (IVF)
Harris
Harris supports guaranteed rights to IVF and supports the ACA, which includes access to coverage before, during and after childbirth. She advocated against a ruling from the Alabama Supreme Court that embryos are children, and therefore cannot be destroyed.
She took a stand against Republicans blocking a bill that would have protected IVF.
Trump
Trump supports access to IVF and said he would require insurance companies to cover the costs but did not detail how he would implement such a requirement.
The Republican platform opposes research using embryonic stem cells (which can be derived from the IVF process).
Maternal health/maternity care
Paid family and medical leave
Harris
In the past, Harris supported 12 weeks of paid leave for most workers, including new parents, caregivers and victims of intimate partner violence. During her presidential run, she has expressed support for paid family and medical leave but has not shared details.
Source link
Share this article: