Will small businesses stay afloat under Amazon testing?
“I do think that mid-size and larger brands can take advantage of the circumstances [at Amazon] and acquire some of the smaller brands that might not be prepared for extra costs coming their way,” said Scott Dicker, market insights director at wellness-focused data technology company SPINS.
According to SPINS, most supplement companies are small businesses, but those that can navigate the new regulations can benefit.
“In the long run, however, [this Amazon policy] should increase the sales and opportunities for all brands putting forth products that meet their label claims by increasing margins and sales,” Dicker said.
He added that it is often the untested products that are selling for low prices, drawing sales and attention away from brands that are priced for fully-dosed ingredients.
For small supplement businesses, staying in the market post Amazon’s latest policy is far more challenging than it is for larger firms in the industry, said Brian Yam, vice president of regulatory affairs and quality assurance at Blue Ocean Regulatory. The Canada-based organization specializes in regulatory consulting for supplement organizations in North America.
“They are devastating in the sense that companies are scared that their products will be suppressed, and they’re working really quickly to figure out how to make sure that doesn’t happen,” he said.
Relying on three firms for testing may mean months of backlog and could drive some companies out of business while waiting for sales to be greenlighted, he said.
NSF previously turned around results in a matter of weeks, but that was prior to Amazon’s April 17 webinar announcing the details of its new policy, according to Yam. If his clients’ experiences are a bellwether, he said that the number of companies demanding testing has gone up considerably since then.
He predicts that the compliance review process will also force small companies to leave Amazon because of indirect costs.
At first glance, the cost of testing—details negotiated directly between testing companies and brands—might not seem exorbitant, ranging from $5,000 to $7,000 annually. For businesses earning $10,000 to $100,000 a month in revenue, a cost of $7,000 a year is minimal when spread across a company’s units per lot, Yam noted. His estimates are based on his clients’ experiences with more complex product formulations.
The real expense comes later, according to Yam, as companies may be surprised by the cost incurred after the compliance review process, which is part of the third-party testing. There, Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) certifications, labels and other documentation are inspected.
The process may reveal to companies that the supplement manufacturers they have relied on for years are, in fact, brokers. In other circumstances, the ‘manufacturer’ could be a distributor of products from other manufacturers based overseas. That discovery could require small firms to move their supply chains to the United States to be compliant, but the associated cost may be prohibitive for some companies, pushing them out of business, Yam said.
Although he welcomes the changes at Amazon, he predicts the industry will become less diversified in the long run, as companies will use similar ingredients and the “good” manufacturers to remain compliant.
“I think it’s going to be interesting for the consumer because they may feel that [Amazon] is not as exciting of a platform as it once was,” Yam said, adding that there will be fewer companies making unconventional product claims.
“I think it’s going to be harder for established [smaller] brands in the Amazon space to stand out.”
‘Devastating’ policies fuel unexpected costs
Source link
Share this article:












