The DeFi Education Fund and Texas-based apparel company Beba have initiated a lawsuit against the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Brought in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas, the complaint questions the manner the SEC has adopted in digital asset regulation, especially its view towards the classification of certain tokens as securities.

Legal Challenge Over Token Classification

The essence of the legal suit is on the $BEBA token, which Beba distributed via airdrops. According to the plaintiffs, these tokens, which can be used to purchase exclusive elements in Beba’s online store, should not be considered as securities. They argue that the method of distribution and the use of the tokens fail to satisfy the Howey Test, which is employed by the SEC to ascertain if an asset is an investment contract and, thus, security.

The Howey Test demands money to be put into a common enterprise that yields an anticipated profit upon the efforts of others. Beba and the DeFi Education Fund claim that these conditions are not met for $BEBA airdrops, as their tokens are distributed for free, and there is no profit expectation based on the work of others.

SEC’s Regulatory Approach Under Scrutiny

The lawsuit additionally charges the SEC with violating the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), which requires federal agencies to develop rules through an open process consisting of public notice and comment. The plaintiffs assert that the SEC’s “regulate by enforcement” strategy has made the crypto industry uncertain and that it has not provided any clear guidelines or public participation. 

The complaint argues that this tactic has stifled innovation and burdened businesses that are looking to capitalize on digital assets in a legitimate manner.

Nathan Hennigh, co-founder of Beba, lamented,

“Like any business owner, I’m always thinking about new and innovative ways to reach more customers and grow support for our products. It’s unfortunate, but we operate in a state of constant uncertainty because of the SEC’s approach to digital assets, such as our $BEBA token.”

Consequently, the SEC has been provided with 60 days to answer the allegations in the complaint. This time frame is standard in proceedings of this kind, allowing the SEC to prepare and file a formal response. 

Read Also: XRP Lawsuit: Ripple CLO Slams SEC’s Soon-to-Be-Revealed $2B Fine