Oriental-Tonic

Best Clean Protein Powder in 2024

By │Published On: April 15, 2024│46.8 min read│Views: 720│0 Comments on Best Clean Protein Powder in 2024│

Slapping a “clean” badge of approval on a product may seem impressive, but what does it actually mean? By our standards, the term “clean” indicates there are minimal ingredients, zero artificial ingredients or sweeteners such as sucralose, and no fillers or thickeners like gums (with the exception of ready-to-drink shakes). This is especially important when it comes to the items you rely on for your health and wellbeing, like protein powder.

Protein comes from a variety of different animal and plant sources. If you want to lose fat but build muscle while

intermittent fasting or calorie counting,

whey protein isolate powder is the gold standard. If you’re following a gluten-free or vegan diet, or allergic to dairy, then plant protein may be a better choice.

To help you narrow down which clean protein powder is right for you, our team tested dozens of options, evaluating them for price, ingredients, protein source, mixability, nutrition, taste, side effects and customer reviews.

Editor’s choice


The

Transparent Labs 100% Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate

offers a clean, protein-packed mix with less lactose and no sugar. This powder’s nutrient profile isn’t limited to just protein, either. It’s also rich in


calcium, iron, and potassium, making it our team’s top pick for best clean protein powder.


Medical disclaimer: This article is intended for educational and informational purposes only. It is not intended as a substitute for medical advice. For health advice, contact a licensed healthcare provider.

Our picks for the best clean protein powder

Compare clean protein powders

Best Clean Protein Powder in 2024

Best clean whey protein powder

Best Clean Protein Powder in 2024

Each scoop of Transparent Labs Whey Protein Isolate contains 28 grams of protein and comes in a variety of flavors to choose from.

Key product features



FI Workout Type


High protein


28 grams

FI Third Party Testing


Sugar


None added

FI Insurance Accepted


Fat


Low

Fortune Icons


Flavors


15

What you should know




At 28 grams of protein per serving, the Transparent Labs Whey Protein Isolate provides the highest protein per serving on our list, with no additional additives or fillers.


  • Our testers found no issues with product mixing.

  • Each serving costs about $2, which is on the more expensive end of the market.

  • This protein powder is best for those focusing on building muscle, shedding fat, and post-workout recovery.

  • This whey protein isolate contains highly absorbable protein. (



    1



    )

Pros



Sourced from grass-fed cows



No artificial dyes or sweeteners

Cons



Higher price point than average



Not suitable for vegan or dairy-free diets



Some flavors are high in sodium

Why we like Transparent Labs 100% Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate as best whey

Transparent Labs Whey Protein Isolate is an easy win for best clean whey protein powder. It’s made from whey protein isolate, a type of protein sourced from cow’s milk that boasts benefits like muscle mass gains and muscle recovery.

Whey protein isolate is a product of minimizing fat and carbohydrate, namely lactose, and is a highly concentrated source of protein. (

2

) Compared to casein, a different type of milk protein, whey is slightly higher in one of the three branched-chain amino acids (BCAA), called leucine, which may give it a leg up on muscle-building potential. (

3

)

“Leucine is a critical component in the process of protein synthesis, which is ultimately necessary for gaining muscle.”

Chris Mohr, Ph.D., RD, Fortune Recommends Advisor

The price of this Transparent Labs protein powder is right around average at $2 per serving, and you truly get what you pay for. We like that the ingredient list is a simple read and that it’s free of many ingredients found in other nutritional supplements like sucralose, aspartame, and fillers.

Aside from being easy to mix into beverages, we love the diverse array of flavors Transparent Labs offers, from blueberry pancake to chocolate peanut butter. Our testers personally couldn’t get enough of the peppermint hot chocolate flavor and are convinced that adding whipped cream and marshmallows would transform your post-workout drink into something truly delicious. The brand also offers an unflavored option that can take on the flavor of whatever you add to it and is soluble in virtually anything.

It’s worth noting that sodium levels are generally higher per serving with this protein powder than others on the market, but opting for the unflavored or vanilla options will help keep sodium levels down if that’s a concern.

We also appreciate that Transparent Labs makes their purity and composition third-party testing visible to the customer and potential customers right on their website, so you know you can trust the contents of what you’re buying.

“The Transparent Labs Whey Protein is Informed Choice Certified, which is an important standard, to know that what’s on the label is in the product—and nothing more,” says Chris Mohr, Ph.D., RD.

What customers are saying

Transparent Labs Whey Protein Isolate has 160 reviews on Amazon, with customers noting great taste and a trusted ingredient list as reasons for liking the product.

“It tastes delicious, has no sugar, mixes perfectly, perfect for keto,” Jeannette C wrote. “I blend it with water real quick in my little Ninja Bullet, and it’s like a milkshake. Delicious!”

“A little more expensive than standard off the shelf proteins, simply based on volume, but the effort and intentionality that goes into producing such a clean and nutritionally rich protein, you’re definitely getting more bang for your buck with this product.”

Nancy S., verified Amazon customer

Solubility—how easy the powder dissolved in water—also earned high praise from reviewers.

“Fantastic product! It tastes great and it blended really well in my shakes,” wrote Caleb H. “It’s my new favorite protein powder.”

What our lab analysis showed

Our third-party lab analysis showed Transparent Labs Whey Protein Isolate did not contain unsafe levels of heavy metals, bisphenols, phthalates, or pesticides.

Specs


Rating
4/5

Third-party testing
Yes

Servings
30

Cost per serving
$2.00

Protein type
Whey protein isolate

Protein per serving
28 grams

Calories per serving
120–150

Carbohydrates per serving
0–3 grams

Fat per serving
0.5–2.5 grams

Best clean casein protein powder:


Legion Casein+


a close-up of a blue and black bag of Legion Athletics's Casein+ protein powder, dutch chocolate flavor, against a bright blue background

Best Clean Casein Protein Powder

a close-up of a blue and black bag of Legion Athletics's Casein+ protein powder, dutch chocolate flavor, against a bright blue background

The brand offers 24–26 grams of casein protein and minimal ingredients, meeting our standards for “clean.”

Key product features



FI Workout Type


High protein


24–26 grams

FI Third Party Testing


Sugar


None added

FI Insurance Accepted


Fat


Low

Fortune Icons


Flavors


4

What you should know




The Legion Casein+ nutrition label provides one of the highest grams of protein per serving we reviewed, from ingredients we trust.


  • Casein is thick in texture and may take extra effort (or liquid) to mix.

  • At about $2.00 per serving, Legion’s Casein+ protein powder costs right around average compared to others on the market.

  • Might be a good choice for those who workout in the evenings, since data suggests a serving of casein protein in the evening may help with recovery and growth. (



    4



    )

  • Legion Athletics offers great customer service and refund policies.

Pros



No artificial dyes or sweeteners



Made with high-quality casein protein



Offers 50–60% of the daily value of calcium per serving



NSF-certified for Sport (no banned substances)

Cons



May be hard to mix on the go



Only available in four flavors



Not suitable for vegan or dairy-free diets



Higher price point per serving than average

Why we like Legion Casein+ as best casein

Legion Casein+ is our pick for best casein protein because it delivers 24 to 26 grams of protein in each serving while remaining a low 110 calories, depending on what flavor you choose. This sets it apart from other casein proteins that are higher in calories and provide less protein. Legion Casein+ sources micellar casein, high-quality casein, from Irish dairy cows. Because of its high-quality ingredient list, Casein+ has a higher price point of about $2 per serving.

Casein can take longer to digest than other forms of protein, like whey. This could be a positive thing for people who like to train into the evening—a slower digestion of protein may help promote muscle growth even while you sleep. (

4

)

“As a dietitian who works with a variety of athletes, I love the utility of casein protein, particularly for those who are training hard, often multiple hours each day. The data suggesting it could make for an effective evening snack is one most athletes can get behind.”

Chris Mohr, Ph.D., RD, Fortune Recommends Advisor

Casein is a complete protein, meaning it contains all essential amino acids necessary for protein synthesis and recovery. (

5

) Each scoop of Legion’s Casein+ also packs 50% to 60% of the daily value for calcium, one of

four critical nutrients many Americans are lacking

.

“While more research is necessary, studies have shown that casein protein can cause gastrointestinal distress in certain individuals. Particularly, if you are lactose intolerant, this may not be a good option for you,” says Jen Roper, Ph.D., CSCS, an associate professor of health and human sciences at Loyola Marymount University. (

6

)

Casein protein powder tends to be thick in texture, and our testers found that it took a little more effort to blend it smoothly into shakes. Relying on a blender ball may not be enough for this protein powder. But, because it’s thicker, it may leave you feeling more satisfied, which may come in handy when post-workout hunger strikes. Therefore, we still gave it a high score for mixability, since it does mix well with the added effort.

Though free of added sugars, the four Legion Casein+ flavors are still pleasantly sweet thanks to monk fruit, stevia, and/or erythritol. Our testers tasted the banana cream pie flavor, a popular choice with a rich, creamy texture and subtle banana taste.

Legion claims to have all products analyzed through third-party testing to make sure you’re getting a pure, honest product; however, we couldn’t verify this for their Casein+ powder. We like that Legion has a “no returns necessary policy” where you can get a full refund without having to return the protein powder. But, we didn’t like navigating their website, which bombards you with ads and email forms.

What customers are saying

The Legion Casein+ has 1,020 reviews on Amazon, with reviewers noting how nicely the powder blends into beverages.

“Really loved this Casein+. Mixes superbly and doesn’t have that chalky unpleasant texture that some casein does,” verified customer Alex wrote.

“This product blended well—1 scoop to 10 oz of water—and the flavor crew at Legion deserve major props. Tastes EXACTLY like cinnamon toast crunch the kids cereal… I will gladly drink this nightly as a bedtime shake!!”

Alan C., verified Amazon customer

Several reviewers, on the other hand, pointed out that they didn’t feel well after consuming the product.

“This product made my stomach hurt and wreaked havoc on my digestion,” Elyssa wrote.

What our lab analysis showed

Our third-party lab analysis showed that Legion Casein+ did not contain unsafe levels of heavy metals, bisphenols, phthalates, or pesticides.

Specs


Rating
4.5/5

Third-party testing
Yes

Servings
30

Cost per serving
$2.00

Protein type
Casein

Protein per serving
24–26 grams

Calories per serving
110–140

Carbohydrates per serving
2–5 grams

Fat per serving
0–2 gram

a close-up of a container of Gnarly Sports Nutrition's Collagen Pro Joint and Connective Tissue Protein supplement against a plain white background

Best Clean Collagen Protein Powder

a close-up of a container of Gnarly Sports Nutrition's Collagen Pro Joint and Connective Tissue Protein supplement against a plain white background

Gnarly Collagen Pro offers 14 grams of protein from bovine collagen, plus vitamins and minerals.

Key product features



Fortune Icons


Flavors


Unflavored

FI Resistance levels


Sizes


Travel options

FI Insurance Accepted


Vitamin C


100% daily value per serving

FI Workout Type


Protein


14 grams

FI Weight Capacity Mattress


Calories


Low

What you should know




Gnarly Collagen Pro contains 14 grams of protein and absolutely no additives. Here’s what else you should know before purchasing it.


  • This product only comes in an unflavored option, meaning you can easily mix it with whichever beverage you’d like.

  • You’ll spend a little less per serving, at $1.67, but you’ll also get a lower amount of protein than other options.

  • May be good for those who are endurance athletes or experience joint pain.

Pros



No artificial ingredients



Available in travel sizes

Cons



Not suitable for vegan or dairy-free diets



Only available in one flavor option



May not be high enough in protein for some at the price point

Why we like Gnarly Collagen Pro as best collagen

Gnarly Collagen Pro is our pick for best clean collagen protein powder, providing 14 grams of protein and an advertised 50 calories per serving. It has zero additives. While many protein powders on the market have a laundry list of ingredients, this formula contains cow-derived hydrolyzed collagen and significant levels of vitamin C, zinc, and copper. Sodium levels are minimal, at 3% daily value per serving, which may be helpful for those following a low-sodium diet. Our reviewers also noted how smooth this protein powder is.

Collagen is a connective tissue protein and is the most abundant protein in the body. It is a structural protein, providing strength and integrity for healthy bones, tendons, and cartilage. A large 2021 review of research studies found that supplementing with collagen may improve muscle recovery and body composition, and reduce joint pain and enhance joint function, but didn’t support muscle protein synthesis. (

7

)

Nutritionally, this product contains 100% of the daily value of vitamin C, which is important in healing connective tissue. (

8

) Plus, you’ll get 111% of the daily value for copper, known for its role in collagen production. (

9

) And, Gnarly Collagen Pro contains 136% of the daily value for zinc, which helps the body make collagen. (

10

)

Gnarly Collagen Pro is only available in an unflavored option, but our testers found this to be a positive characteristic. They enjoyed the fact that there truly is no discernable taste when mixed into liquids such as coffee or Powerade.

Gnarly Collagen Pro is both NSF Content Certified and NSF Sport Certified, meaning it undergoes a review of heavy metals and label claim testing. It’s also tested for banned substances, ensuring you’re getting a safe product that meets label claims.

“NSF Sport Certification is important to me, as a sports dietitian, since it ensures the product is safe for athletes and that there are no banned substances included in the product itself.”

Chris Mohr, Ph.D., RD, Fortune Recommends Advisor

What customers are saying

While Gnarly Collagen Pro only has 22 reviews on Amazon, the overall consensus is that most customers enjoy the product for its ease of mixability, flavorless taste, simple ingredients, and support in injury recovery and other conditions.

“Mixes well with other flavored beverages so you can put in most anything,” verified buyer Steve wrote. “Good price for a quality product.”

“Love the creaminess it adds to a smoothie,” another Amazon customer wrote. “Using for support with strength training and running.”

Specs


Rating
4.3/5

Third-party testing
Yes

Servings
30

Cost per serving
$1.67

Protein type
Bovine collagen

Protein per serving
14 grams

Calories per serving
50

Carbohydrates per serving
0 grams

Fat per serving
0 grams

a closeup of Transparent Labs's Grass-Fed Protein+ peanut butter chocolate chip-flavored protein bar in its wrapper
a closeup of Transparent Labs's Grass-Fed Protein+ peanut butter chocolate chip-flavored protein bar in its wrapper

Transparent Labs’s Grass-Fed Protein+ Bars contain 15 grams of protein and are free of artificial sweeteners, coloring, and preservatives

Key product features



FI Third Party Testing


Sugar


No artificial sweeteners

FI Serving Size


Ingredients


Whole foods

FI Shipping Mattress


Subscription


Available

What you should know




At 15 grams of protein per bar, the Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Protein+ Bars are a high-quality, on-the-go protein boost.


  • At $3.33 a bar, this is a more expensive protein option than many others on the market.

  • This is a great option for people who are looking for an alternative to traditional protein powder.

  • Contains 3 grams of filling fiber for a satisfying snack.

Pros



Made with high-quality whey protein isolate



Contains real ingredients

Cons



Higher price point per serving than average



High in sodium and saturated fat



Not suitable for vegan, peanut-free, egg-free, or dairy-free diets

Why we like Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Protein+ Bars as best protein bars

Protein bars like Transparent Labs’s Grass-Fed Protein+ Bars can be a convenient alternative to blending shakes, making increasing your protein intake easier by taking it on-the-go. But this convenience does come at a higher price point. The brand sells its only flavor, peanut butter chocolate chip, in a 12-pack, which comes to $3.33 per bar.

You’ll find that Transparent Labs sticks to providing high-quality protein from grass-fed cattle, offering an impressive amino acid profile that complements fitness and overall wellness. Unlike protein bars made with refined sugars and natural flavors, these bars utilize naturally sweet ingredients like tapioca syrup (from cassava root), honey, and dates. We like that Transparent Labs remains transparent, and explains every ingredient for the bars on their website.

Our testers noted that the bars have a defined peanut butter and chocolate taste, with real pieces of chocolate that melt in your mouth. If you find it hard to stomach protein bars, consider still giving these a try. Unlike other protein bar brands, this one doesn’t have the typically chalky textures and super sweet aftertaste, while also providing a soft and chewy texture with some dryness.

If you’re keeping careful watch of your macros, it’s important to know that every bar has 16 grams of fat, 23 grams of carbohydrates, and 15 grams of protein. Additionally, there’s also 3 grams of fiber, which may support gut health. (

11

)

“Fiber has been called a ‘nutrient of concern’ since most Americans aren’t eating enough of this important nutrient. Fiber supports heart health, gut health, and just wellbeing as a whole.”

Chris Mohr, Ph.D., RD, Fortune Recommends Advisor

For those following a heart-healthy diet, the protein bars have 25% of the daily value of saturated fat, which the American Heart Association advises reducing to protect heart health. (

12

) Moreover, they’re higher in sodium, at 12% of your daily value per bar. Neither of those make it a bar that’s “off limits,” but rather a reminder that these should be used as a complement to a diet balanced with plenty of variety and nutrition, instead of a regular staple.

These bars also aren’t free of several common allergens and are not fit for people allergic to peanuts, eggs, or dairy.

Specs


Rating
4.2/5

Third-party testing
N/A

Servings
12

Cost per serving
$3.33

Protein type
Whey protein isolate

Protein per serving
15 grams

Calories per serving
280

Carbohydrates per serving
23 grams

Fat per serving
16 grams

a close-up of a blue, translucent container of Ora Organic's So Lean and So Clean plant-based superfood protein powder

Best Clean Vegan Protein Powder

a close-up of a blue, translucent container of Ora Organic's So Lean and So Clean plant-based superfood protein powder

This blend has 21 grams of pea and rice protein, digestive enzymes to help prevent gas and bloating, and antioxidant-rich superfoods.

Key product features



FI Serving Size


Ingredients


Organic and plant-based

FI Workout Type


High protein


21–22 grams per serving

FI Shipping Mattress


Subscription


Available

Fortune Icons


Flavors


4

What you should know




With 21 grams of protein from organic pea and rice protein, Ora Organic’s plant-based protein powder is a great option for those with specific dietary preferences or allergies.


  • While our testers like having flavor options, they also enjoyed this unflavored powder that could be easily mixed into other beverages.

  • At $2 per serving, this is right around the average cost for protein powders on the market.

  • The supplement is excellent for individuals who may have certain allergies; it’s soy-free, dairy-free, and gluten-free.

Pros



No artificial sweeteners, colors, or flavors



Suitable for a wide-range of special diets

Cons



Only available in four flavors



High in sodium compared to others

Why we like Ora Organic So Lean & So Clean Plant-Based Superfood Powder as best vegan

Some research reports a higher prevalence of iron-deficiency among people who are vegetarian, a category that includes vegans. (

13

) Our top pick for best clean vegan protein powder, Ora Organic Plant-Based Superfood Powder is a helpful tool for vegans to add iron to their diet and limit their risk of deficiency or insufficiency.

This vegan protein powder contains 21–22 grams of protein from organic peas and rice, just 2.5–3 grams of fat, 4–5 grams of carbohydrates, and delivers 33–39% of the daily recommended dose for iron. It’s also chock-full of other nutritious vegetables and grains, including organic quinoa, organic broccoli, and organic cranberry.

“Research has shown that those who do not eat animal protein may have higher protein needs than those who do, to ensure all essential amino acid needs are met. (

14

) Adding in a quality vegan protein powder, such as this, offers the ability to increase protein intake in a simple, yet effective, manner,” says Chris Mohr, Ph.D., RD.

Some protein powder users may struggle with digestive issues from undigested protein. Thankfully, Ora Organic Plant-Based Superfood Powder adds digestive enzymes to its formula, which may assist in breaking down plant nutrients to ease digestion. If you’re seeking a product that offers complete protein, you found it. Their formula supplies the essential amino acids as well as non-essential.

“It’s important to note that consumption of amino acid supplements can have some side effects. Bloating, nausea, diarrhea, etc., have often been reported with such supplements, likely due to the lactose content. This protein powder could be beneficial for those who are sensitive to other products on the market.” (

15

)

Jen Roper, Ph.D., CSCS, Fortune Recommends Advisor

While the protein powder only comes in four flavors, we like that at least one of those is unflavored, so it can be used more widely in foods and beverages. Also, this brand caters to people who prefer simpler flavors like chocolate or vanilla chai.

Not only does Ora Organic go the extra mile to provide organic ingredients, but the company also does third-party testing  for contaminants, heavy metals, potency of ingredients, and potential pathogens. Test results are available to view on their website.

If their product piques your interest, remember that it only contains 20 servings, so you’ll run out more quickly than you would with other protein powders. But, Ora Organic has a subscription program for every 30 to 60 days to help replenish your stock.

If you have high blood pressure and follow a low-sodium diet, it’s worth noting that this protein blend is high in sodium and provides 11–17% of the daily value, which is higher than other options.

What customers are saying

Ora Organic So Lean & So Clean Plant-Based Superfood Powder has 5,941 reviews on Amazon. Many customers like how the protein powder tastes, as well as how it doesn’t result in bloating like some other options.

“Have been using this protein for the past 2 years and I could not recommend it more,” verified buyer Sunny wrote. “It has healthy ingredients and gets rid of that nasty bloat that other powders contain. As someone who can’t handle whey protein, this has been a great alternative.”

“I have tried sooo many plant based protein powders and this is my favorite by far!!! The first one to not make me bloat,”

Rachel B., verified Amazon customer

Unsavory reviews were rare, however, they were related to taste and texture. “I appreciate that this protein powder is clean, but the taste is not great,” verified buyer Joanna said. “It has a chalky texture that stays in your mouth after you drink it.”

Specs


Rating
4.4/5

Third-party testing
Yes

Servings
20

Cost per serving
$1.99

Protein type
Pea and rice

Protein per serving
21 grams

Calories per serving
120–130

Carbohydrates per serving
4–5 grams

Fat per serving
2.5–3 grams

a close-up of a dark green bag of Cymbiotika's Plant Protein supplement on a white oak surface against a bright green background, with a scoop of the powder sitting in front of it

Best Clean Plant-Based Protein Powder

a close-up of a dark green bag of Cymbiotika's Plant Protein supplement on a white oak surface against a bright green background, with a scoop of the powder sitting in front of it

This protein powder blends organic hemp, spirulina, and pea protein as well as greens, fiber, digestive enzymes, and probiotics.

Key product features



FI Workout Type


High protein


20 grams per serving

Fortune Icons


Flavor


Vanilla

FI Insurance Accepted


Fat


Low

FI Shipping Mattress


Subscription


Available

What you should know




Cymbiotika’s formula supplies 20 grams of protein from organic hemp, organic spirulina, and organic pea protein.


  • Our testers found the initial flavor to be smooth, but followed by an earthy aftertaste.

  • It’s more expensive than average, at $3.67 per serving.

  • It’s good for those who want more than protein, but plant nutrients and digestive support too.

  • It provides fiber, digestive enzymes, prebiotics, and probiotics to support gut health.

  • The formula is made up of proprietary blends.

Pros



No artificial dyes or sweeteners



Offers 100% of the daily values of vitamins E and K

Cons



Only available in one flavor



Expensive compared to other similar products



Contains proprietary blends

Why we like Cymbiotika Plant Protein as best plant-based

Cymbiotika Plant Protein is our pick for best clean plant-based protein powder thanks to its blend of 20 grams of protein and organic ingredients that include greens,

prebiotics and probiotics

, and significant amounts of other essential nutrients including fiber, iron, and vitamin E. The formula also includes L-glutamine, which may help with weight loss and performance fatigue, which could help extend your workout. (

16

,

17

) Alpha-GPC is also present in small amounts in the supplement, which helps maintain choline levels and may therefore benefit athletic performance and muscle protein synthesis. (

18

)

Our testers liked the nutrient profile of this blend, with its 130 calories, 10 grams of carbohydrates, and 2.5 grams of fat. Overall, Cymbiotika Plant Protein has more carbohydrates than other protein powders, which are critical for exercise. Additionally, you’ll get 100% of the daily value for vitamin E and

vitamin K,

and 25% of your daily value for iron. The sodium content, at 17% of the recommended daily intake, is worth paying attention to, since the American Heart Association notes excess sodium may increase your risk for heart condition. (

19

)

When adding the blend into a shaker cup, our testers found it was easy to mix despite its slightly grainy texture. Our testers also noted an unexpected, earthy aftertaste that followed the product’s original vanilla flavor. This might be because the ingredients list carries a wide range of raw greens, adaptogenic mushrooms, and fiber-rich ingredients.

One thing to consider before purchasing this blend is that it contains multiple proprietary blends, which appear on the supplement facts label as grouped ingredients under one title. The problem with proprietary blends is that it conceals the amount of each ingredient in the formula. Further, there was no sign of third-party testing.

Ease of digestion is another thing to note when discussing this protein powder. One of our testers had symptoms the morning after drinking this blend. “I have been gassy and bloated since drinking this yesterday, woke up this morning extremely bloated and gassy still almost 18 hours later,” they wrote.

What customers are saying

Cymbiotika’s Plant Protein has garnered 47 reviews on Amazon. Reviews of the product’s taste were mixed.

“If you’re looking for something that’s not full of junk that will keep you full and doesn’t taste bad, this is great… Just have reasonable expectations and plan on using it in shakes rather than just with milk unless you’re genuinely into earthy flavors.”

Jen S., verified Amazon customer

“This supplement is not necessarily bad tasting, but it does not taste good,” Joseph S. added.

Specs


Rating
3.2/5

Third-party testing
Unknown

Servings
24

Cost per serving
$3.67

Protein type
Hemp, spirulina, and pea

Protein per serving
20 grams

Calories per serving
130

Carbohydrates per serving
10 grams

Fat per serving
2.5 grams

a close-up of Naked Nutrition's Naked Goat 100% premium grass-fed goat whey protein powder

Best Clean Goat Protein Powder

a close-up of Naked Nutrition's Naked Goat 100% premium grass-fed goat whey protein powder

This protein powder’s single ingredient—goat whey protein concentrate—makes it a simple, clean protein option.

Key product features



FI Workout Type


High protein


23 grams per serving

Fortune Icons


Flavor


Unflavored

FI Diet Type


Fat


Low

FI Insurance Accepted


Carbs


Low

FI Shipping Mattress


Subscription


Available

What you should know




Naked Nutrition Goat Whey Protein Powder is comparable to whey protein isolate, with 23 grams of protein per serving.


  • At about $2.33 per serving, this is more expensive than average.

  • Great option for those with a mild lactose sensitivity.

  • Sourced from grass-fed Wisconsin cattle.

Pros



High-quality protein with BCAAs



No artificial ingredients



Responsive customer service

Cons



Refunds only on unused items



Not suitable for vegan or dairy-free diets



More expensive than average

Why we like Naked Nutrition Goat Whey Protein Powder as best goat protein

Naked Nutrition Goat Whey Protein Powder steals the top spot for best clean goat protein powder with its one ingredient formula—goat whey concentrate. Whey concentrate undergoes less processing than whey protein isolate. “This doesn’t make whey protein concentrate ‘bad’ per se, but whey concentrate is generally higher in lactose and fat compared to whey isolate,” says Chris Mohr, Ph.D., RD.

Milk coming from a cow or goat is generally the same nutritionally, but some research suggests goat milk is more easily digestible, which could be important for those who may not tolerate dairy protein from cow milk. (

20

)

Naked Nutrition’s product also impressed us with its nutrient profile, which is comparable to whey protein isolate. Each two scoop serving provides 110 calories, 2 grams of carbohydrates, 0.5 grams of fat, and 23 grams of protein.

Similar to other whey protein powders, Naked Nutrition is a complete protein, providing all essential amino acids (EAAs) including branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs), which may reduce muscle soreness after weight lifting, particularly if overall protein intake isn’t optimal. (

21

)

“While BCAAs are important, they aren’t necessary in a diet that already provides adequate quantities and quality of protein. More isn’t necessarily better, unless protein intake is inadequate and needs aren’t being met.”

Chris Mohr, Ph.D., RD, Fortune Recommends Advisor

Naked Nutrition Goat Protein is also third-party tested and prides itself on having “nothing to hide.” We like that it’s free of soy and gluten. Naked Nutrition’s products are certified gluten-free, so those with celiac disease or a gluten intolerance can trust this product.

The company’s customer service was not only easy to access via live chat, but also impressively responsive, quickly addressing our inquiry even outside regular business hours.

What customers are saying

Naked Nutrition Goat Whey Protein Powder has 764 Amazon reviews, with many reviewers noting how easy the product is to digest.

“I like that there are no artificial sweeteners or other additives, just pure goat’s milk. This doesn’t bother my stomach like cow’s milk whey protein powder.”

Jean K., verified Amazon customer

“I like it, it has a very slight goat milk flavor but nothing too bad,” Nermine H. said. “I love the quality and it doesn’t get me bloated and digests well.”

While most reviewers enjoy the goat protein powder overall, the price point was a sore spot for many customers.

“The only reason I gave it a 4 instead of a 5 is that it’s kind of expensive,” Max H. wrote.

Specs


Rating
4/5

Third-party testing
Yes

Servings
30

Cost per serving
$2.33

Protein type
Goat whey protein concentrate

Protein per serving
23 grams

Calories per serving
110

Carbohydrates per serving
2 grams

Fat per serving
0.5 grams

a closeup of Vital Protein's Vital Performance Protein chocolate shake in its container

Best Clean Protein Powder for Muscle Gain

a closeup of Vital Protein's Vital Performance Protein chocolate shake in its container

The bovine-collagen protein powder boasts a minimal ingredient list while delivering a protein count of 25 grams per scoop.

Key product features



FI Workout Type


High protein


25 grams per serving

Fortune Icons


Flavors


4

FI Diet Type


Fat


Low

FI Shipping Mattress


Subscription


Available

What you should know




Vital Proteins stands out above the rest thanks to an ingredient list that provides 25 grams of protein without any unnecessary fillers.


  • At about $1.43 per serving, Vital Proteins is a more affordable option than many others on the market.

  • This is best for people looking to build muscle and promote healthy tendons, bones, and joints.

  • For those looking for an energy boost, the cold brew coffee flavor has 100mg of caffeine.

Pros



May support bones, tendons, and joint health, as well as muscle

Cons



Not suitable for vegan or dairy-free diets



Only available in four flavors



Only 21 servings per container

Why we like Vital Protein Vital Performance Protein Powder as best for muscle gain

We chose Vital Protein Vital Performance Protein Power as the best clean protein powder for muscle gain because it supplies 25 grams protein from bovine collagen and milk protein isolate, and has a minimal ingredient list.

Collagen protein is abundant in muscle tissues. (

24

) Since collagen contains unique peptides that can promote the production of collagen in our body, research says it may promote the building of connective tissue proteins, which may support muscles. (

25

) While researchers are still studying the connection between collagen and muscle development, we found this protein powder to have a few exemplary qualities that many kinds of athletes can benefit from.

The protein powder contains 130 calories, no fat, and 6 grams of carbohydrates from glucose, an energy source. It also includes MCT oil, which contains medium-chain fatty acids that can be absorbed and readily available as an energy source for muscle. (

26

)

Vital Proteins gives customers four flavor options to choose from: chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, and cold brew coffee. One downside is that there’s no unflavored option for those who may prefer a flavorless powder to add to coffee or shakes. If you workout into the evening, keep in mind that their coffee flavor has 100mg of caffeine.

“It’s also important to consider other sources of caffeine that you ingest throughout the day, as the maximum recommended intake is 400 mg per day. Additionally, caffeine is known to impact sleep quality, which is vital for exercise recovery.” (

27

)

Jen Roper, Ph.D., CSCS, Fortune Recommends Advisor

We like that Vital Proteins products are made in an NSF-certified and cGMP-certified facility so we know manufacturing standards are up to par. Their products also undergo third-party testing, however, those reports don’t appear on their website. Additionally, this collagen protein powder is more affordable than many others on this list, costing $1.43 per serving.

If you have any problems with your order, their customer service is fairly quick and painless. The website’s live chat option gets you connected to a real person, quickly, which we greatly appreciate.

What customers are saying

The Vital Performance Protein Powder has nearly 5,000 reviews on Amazon, with many customers singing the praises of the powder’s quality.

“Good alone or mixed with other shakes. Nice combo of whey and collagen,” Joe V. wrote.

“I have tried many expensive powders that are gritty and leave me feeling bloated. This one is the best so far… I am very hopeful that it makes a difference for my training. Mixed the vanilla with water in a smoothie.”

J. Parker, verified Amazon customer

Nutritionally, a few customers aren’t happy that the product contains added sugars, coming from glucose, which seems to be an ingredient mainly used as a carbohydrate or energy source.

Specs


Rating
4.8/5

Third-party testing
Yes

Servings
21

Cost per serving
$1.43

Protein type
Bovine collagen and milk protein isolate

Protein per serving
25 grams

Calories per serving
130

Carbohydrates per serving
6 grams

Fat per serving
0 grams

a closeup of a container of Orgain's Keto Collagen Protein Powder for hair, skin, nail, and joint support

Best Clean Keto Protein Powder

a closeup of a container of Orgain's Keto Collagen Protein Powder for hair, skin, nail, and joint support

This collagen-based protein powder is as keto-friendly as it is clean, with only a handful of ingredients

Key product features



Fortune Icons


Flavors


2

FI Third Party Testing


Sugar


None added

FI Diet Type


Carbs


Low

FI Shipping Mattress


Subscription


Available

What you should know




Completely free of additives, Orgain Keto Collagen Protein Powder supplies 10 grams of protein in each 90-calorie scoop.


  • This is an excellent option for people following a keto diet.

  • At $2.10 per serving, this costs slightly above average compared to other protein powders on the market.

  • It’s naturally sweetened with stevia extract.

Pros



Made with easily absorbed collagen peptides



No artificial sweeteners, colors, or flavors



Less than 100 calories per serving

Cons



Only available in two flavors



Only 20 servings per container

Why we like Orgain Keto Collagen Protein Powder as best keto

If you’re a follower of the keto diet—eating low carb and higher fat foods—you might be searching for a clean protein that fits the bill. We like Orgain Keto Collagen Protein Powder, a grass-fed bovine collagen protein powder with just six ingredients that’s completely free of additives.

It’s fairly common for keto fans to keep a close watch on their calorie intake in the name of weight loss. That said, this protein powder only supplies 90 calories per scoop. Its fat comes from medium-chain triglycerides (MCTs), which may lower symptoms of keto-induction according to one study. (

22

)

“While some symptoms of keto-induction may be lower, those who experience abdominal pain may have greater symptom frequency and severity. But, if that is not a symptom you deal with, this protein is a great option.” (

22

)

Jen Roper, Ph.D., CSCS, Fortune Recommends Advisor

Orgain Keto Collagen Protein Powder is allergen-friendly and suitable for those who are soy-free, gluten-free, and dairy-free. Plus, it contains 25% of the daily value of iron. But the product isn’t free of drawbacks. Keep in mind, it only provides 10 grams of protein, to satisfy the keto 2:1 ration. It’s common for protein powder users to want at least 20 to 30 grams of protein per serving, but since this is a keto-specific formula, there’s much less.

It’s important to keep in mind that collagen should be considered more as a means of providing functional peptides (short protein fragments) that support body connective tissue health, not necessarily meeting general daily protein requirements.

“Collagen is a poor form of protein itself, with little effect on protein synthesis,” says Chris Mohr, Ph.D., RD. (

23

) “While collagen may have other beneficial outcomes, it shouldn’t be used with the intention of providing quality protein to the diet and particularly not in place of other, high quality protein options like a whey protein isolate.”

This protein powder costs right around average, at $2.10 per serving. And with only 20 servings per container, you may run out of it fast. Like many other brands, Orgain does have a subscribe-and-save option that will save you 15%.

What customers are saying

Orgain’s Keto Collagen Protein Powder has over 15,500 reviews on Amazon. While reviews on taste are mixed, most customers agree that the product mixes well, particularly in hot beverages like coffee.

“Orgain’s keto protein powder has become my go-to choice for maintaining a low-carb lifestyle. The taste is fantastic, and it mixes well with both water and almond milk. I appreciate that it’s not overly sweet, and the smooth texture makes it enjoyable to drink.”

Lauren Hudson, verified Amazon customer

“There are many good brands of hydrolyzed collagen powder, this one seems to have the best flavor for the price,” wrote an anonymous verified Amazon customer.

Some reviewers noted how they wished each serving contained more protein, as they felt 10 grams per serving was too little for a protein supplement.

Specs


Rating
3.7/5

Third-party testing
No

Servings
20

Cost per serving
$2.10

Protein type
Bovine collagen

Protein per serving
10 grams

Calories per serving
90

Carbohydrates per serving
3 grams

Fat per serving
5 grams

a closeup of a 24-pack of Slate Milk High-Protein Shake cans, french vanilla flavor
a closeup of a 24-pack of Slate Milk High-Protein Shake cans, french vanilla flavor

Slate Milk’s ready-to-drink milk-based shake packs 20 grams of protein per can.

Key product features



FI Workout Type


High protein


20 grams per serving

Fortune Icons


Flavors


7

FI Diet Type


Fat


Low

FI Insurance Accepted


Carbs


Low

FI Third Party Testing


Sugar


None added

FI Shipping Mattress


Subscription


Available

What you should know




At 20 grams of protein per shake, Slate Milk High Protein Shake is a convenient option for consumers looking for a lactose-free protein boost.


  • At about $3.00 per can, these shakes are a more expensive protein option.

  • This is a great choice for people who are lactose-free and looking for something that’s easy to digest.

  • The energy varieties contain caffeine.

Pros



Available in variety packs



Build-your-own box option

Cons



Energy varieties are not suitable for those with caffeine sensitivity



More expensive than average

Why we like Slate Milk High Protein Shake as best protein shake

We like Slate Milk High Protein Shake as the best clean protein shake because it’s a simple, on-the-go option teeming with 20 grams of protein from ultra-filtered milk along with good nutrition. Aside from its richness in protein, the shake is low in fat, only has 100 calories per serving, and is free of added sugars. The supplement comes in seven flavors, including classic chocolate, mocha, and french vanilla. The brand also lets you order a combination of flavors in their variety pack, so you can try more than one at a time.

We also like that Slate Milk has an energy variety pack option, with latte shakes that contain caffeine for a morning protein pick-me-up. However, it has almost as much caffeine as two cups of coffee, so if you’re caffeine sensitive you may want to consider another flavor or the time of day you’re drinking it.

“As someone who is caffeine sensitive, I tend to avoid all things caffeine. Otherwise, you may experience some unwanted side effects such as jitters, anxiousness, and upset stomach to name a few. So, be mindful of your normal intake to avoid these effects.” (

28

)

Jen Roper, Ph.D., CSCS, Fortune Recommends Advisor

The brand is mindful of people with lactose intolerance. Their ultra-filtration processing effectively removes lactose from the shakes. The shakes are also low in carbohydrates so they’re suitable for those following a keto diet, too.

Conveniently, Slate Milk is shelf stable so you don’t have to worry about it going bad quickly. That said, you may question how “clean” the product is because of some of its ingredients; but without some of them—like dipotassium phosphate—the product would go bad faster. It’s worth noting that almost all ready-to-go protein shakes on the market include a source of gum, which helps with thickening and stabilizing.

In addition to offering a quality source of protein, the ready-to-drink shake also offers 25% of the daily value of vitamin D, which has numerous benefits and has been defined as a shortfall nutrient in the diets of Americans. (

29

) Not to mention, there’s plenty of calcium and vitamin A at 40 % and 25 % of the daily value, respectively.

What customers are saying

Slate Milk High Protein Shake has 1,575 reviews on Amazon, the majority of which are positive. Customers particularly like how the shake keeps them satisfied longer than other products.

“This is my first time trying this brand. I have many protein shakes that have left me more hungry an hour later,” verified Amazon customer J. Flemming wrote. “This shake holds me over for hours!”

“Delicious and filling drink. I’ve really enjoyed how I feel after having this High Protein Shake. I will definitely be ordering more.”

Adam, verified Amazon customer

Some reviewers wrote how they noted an aftertaste with some of the flavors, particularly vanilla and chocolate. “Classic chocolate and dark chocolate are pretty good,” Savannah A. wrote. “The classic chocolate has more sweet aftertaste but its not bad. The vanilla was horrible. I wouldn’t drink it.”

Specs


Rating
4.3/5

Third-party testing
N/A

Servings
12

Cost per serving
$3.00

Protein type
Milk

Protein per serving
20 grams

Calories per serving
100

Carbohydrates per serving
2–15 grams

Fat per serving
1 gram

How we test supplements

Our team understands the role supplements play in enhancing your health and wellness. When it comes to choosing the best clean protein powder, it’s important to consider the ingredients and how the product makes you feel, as well as how it impacts your fitness goals.

Our goal is to provide you with easy-to-understand insights that help you make the right choice for your own health and wellbeing.


You read our full supplement testing methodology here.

Testing criteria

Efficacy—40%

Consumers take dietary supplements to achieve specific goals and improve their overall wellbeing. That’s why our main focus when we evaluate protein powders is efficacy. Before recommending anything, we need to make sure a product delivers on its promised benefits.

Here’s what we look for when assessing efficacy:


  • Clinical evidence

  • Calories per serving

  • Dose efficacy

  • Synergistic effects

  • Proprietary blends

Safety and side effects—35%

Our top priority is consumer safety. Before recommending a product, we examine its potential health risks, adverse effects, and safety profiles.

We evaluate:


  • Reported side effects

  • Third-party testing

  • Manufacturer accreditation

  • Artificial sweeteners

Value—20%

Value doesn’t just imply price—we look at a product’s value based on what you receive for the price you pay. Finding a high value protein powder doesn’t mean finding the cheapest option, but identifying a product that provides the health benefits, quality, efficacy, and satisfaction you’re looking for at a price that’s fair.

The main thing we look at in this rating is:

Customer experience—5%

Customer experience can make or break how you feel about a product, and how likely you’ll be to buy that product again.

To evaluate customer experience we assess:


  • Ease of purchase

  • Shipping and returns

  • Customer support

About our chemical lab analysis

Our dedicated team of product testers have hands-on experience using the protein powders we evaluate. In this article, we incorporate their insightful feedback, including both the positive and less favorable aspects of each supplement. However, our commitment to transparency doesn’t end there.

To guarantee the products we recommend are from reputable brands adhering to industry best practices for quality and safety, we took the extra step of subjecting them to independent, third-party testing through ISO 17025 accredited lab Ellipse Analytics. Many of the products underwent thorough analysis for safety, purity, and ingredient accuracy. The testing confirms the accuracy of ingredient amounts and ensures the absence of harmful levels of contaminants, pesticides, heavy metals, bisphenols, and phthalates.

The results of these assessments are incorporated into the individual reviews.


Medical disclaimer: This article is intended for educational and informational purposes only. It is not intended as a substitute for medical advice. For health advice, contact a licensed healthcare provider.


How we chose the best clean protein powder

Price

High-quality protein powders have a reputation for being high-ticket. Because budget is a concern for many, we’ve outlined the protein powder’s cost per serving for each category. In our list, protein powders range between $1.43 to $3.67 per serving; therefore, many protein powders cost around $2.00 on average. Some companies offer discounts when you subscribe or sign up for the first time. But price is something important to consider, because more often than not, you’re looking for a protein supplement for the long-haul.

Protein per serving

On average, protein powders pack around 20 grams of protein per serving. Some may want more protein while others might look for a different balance of carbohydrates to protein, depending on their overall goal. That’s why protein per serving played into our top choices. While one of our selections contains less than 20 grams of protein, it is specific to those following a keto diet who have to closely monitor protein intake. Also, because it is collagen, which is supplemented to deliver collagen peptides, total protein content is less important than how much peptides are provided.

Ingredients

We prioritized brands making formulas with the fewest ingredients possible, or formulas with natural ingredients such as whole foods. Artificial sweeteners such as sucralose, aspartame, and sugar alcohols are non-nutritive but common in protein powder supplements on the market. Here, we’ve only included those with natural sweeteners such as stevia and monk fruit. We also limited our selection to those without any fillers or thickeners like gums; however ready-to-drink shakes, such as the Slate Milk High Protein Shake, require a gum to stabilize the mixture of ingredients.


What to look for in clean protein powder

The growing number of available protein powders can be overwhelming. But, the truth is, choosing the best clean protein powder comes down to several factors: the protein source, your fitness goals, cost, and taste.

Protein source

Your dietary needs drive what source of protein is best for you. If you’re lactose intolerant, you could choose either a lactose-free whey protein or a plant-based protein. However, if you’re following a dairy-free diet, your options are limited to plant-based proteins only. Moreover, if you’re a person living with digestive issues, you may consider options that include probiotics and/or digestive enzymes to help relieve gas and stomach pain.

Fitness goals

Whether you want to lose weight and preserve muscle mass, or you’re training to bulk up, you’ll be focused on the nutrition a certain protein powder provides. For weight loss and retaining muscle, you may seek a lower calorie, high protein option. However, if you’re wanting to add mass, you might be after a higher calorie formula. A moderate amount of calories and protein in a supplement may be fit for you if you are simply trying to increase your protein intake while exercising.

Cost

Protein powders can get costly, and if you’re supplementing daily, you may be replacing your container every month. That said, you want to make sure your protein choice fits your monthly budget.

Taste

Flavors matter when it comes to protein because if it doesn’t taste good, you’re not going to drink it. Some brands make sample packs so you can try out their products without buying a full tub, while others will let you have a refund solely from being dissatisfied with the taste. If sampling the protein powder beforehand isn’t possible, customer reviews can be helpful in guiding your path to the best tasting protein powders.


FAQs


What is the cleanest, safest protein powder?



After careful consideration of quality, nutritional value, protein content, and available flavor options, our top pick is Transparent Labs Whey Protein Isolate. Perfect for people on the path to building lean muscle and gaining strength, the protein powder is jam-packed with 28 grams of protein per serving. Moreover, it provides low amounts of fats and carbs, and provides just 120


–


150


calories per scoop. Sourced from grass-fed cows on hormone- and antibiotic-free American farms, its clean blend has no gluten, added sugars, or artificial flavors. Lastly, you’ll have plenty of flavors to entice your taste buds given their selection of 15 appealing flavors.


Which protein powder has no heavy metals?



In 2018, the Clean Label Project examined 133 protein powder supplements for heavy metals, like arsenic and lead, and heavy metals were detected in every single one. That said, it’s likely that most protein powders contain some heavy metals. (



30



) The question is whether there is enough, or a clinically relevant amount, to cause concern. Your safest bet is to select a protein powder that regularly checks their formula for high levels of heavy metals through third-party testing.


Is whey or plant protein better?



The right answer depends on your lifestyle and goals. If you can tolerate dairy and are looking to build muscle, then whey protein would benefit you. If you follow a vegan or vegetarian diet, or have a dairy allergy, then your best choice would be plant protein.


How do you know if protein powder is good quality?



Firstly, good quality protein will come from a reputable brand that is open about their third-party testing results and where their protein comes from. Secondly, a quality protein powder has simple and recognizable ingredients.

   <em>
    These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any diseases.
   </em>



   Dr. Christopher Mohr is an internationally recognized subject matter expert and speaker and performance coach. He works closely with some of the largest corporations in the world including Deloitte, Delta Airlines, Johnson &amp; Johnson, and more to help busy executives develop the energy to thrive personally and professionally. Chris was a member of the Men’s Health Magazine advisory board for 10 years, co-authored a NY Times Bestseller with LL Cool J, called LL Cool J’s Platinum Workout, and worked as the sports nutritionist for the Cincinnati Bengals and select WWE wrestlers.



   Dr. Jen Roper is an associate professor of Health and Human Sciences at Loyola Marymount University. She received her Ph.D. in Physical Education, Sports and Exercise Science in 2015 from the University of New Mexico, with a specialization in Exercise Science and Biomechanics. She has been a Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist from the National Strength and Conditioning Association since 2014.



   Dr Robert Wildman (“Dr Rob”) is a globally renowned exercise, fitness, and nutrition expert who speaks around the world on exercise and sport nutrition, and continues to work with professional and elite athletes to achieve their highest level of performance as well as health and fitness. Rob received his Ph.D. from The Ohio State University, earned his M.S. from Florida State University, and earned his B.S. from the University of Pittsburgh. He is also a registered and licensed dietitian.



   Lily is a Brooklyn-based writer and editor with over seven years of experience in health media. As a former Fitness Coach, Lily’s editorial prowess has largely focused on fitness, nutrition, and weight management. She has also spent a fair share of time in testing labs, analyzing everything from protein powders to yoga mats. Her work has appeared in Verywell Fit, Verywell Mind, Health, and more.



   Jessica is an editor and writer who specializes in fitness, health, nutrition, and science content. Previously, she was an editor for Popular Mechanics and Bicycling, where she covered pro cycling news, wrote how-to guides, and tested all the latest and greatest bike gear. She was also a regular shoe tester and contributor for Runner’s World. These days, you can often find her skiing or riding her mountain bike, and racing with the F1RE female enduro team.
   Kelly has a multifaceted background in elder care, health care, and copywriting. She has worked for organizations such as A Place For Mom and Homecare.com, which gave her the opportunity to work closely with families, providing reliable information to help them make informed decisions about their loved one’s health, safety, and quality of life.

Source link

LivPure Quiz

Written by : Editorial team of BIPNs

Main team of content of bipns.com. Any type of content should be approved by us.

Share this article:

Leave A Comment