SmoothieDiet

Multiple Micronutrient Supplements in Humanitarian Emergencies: A State of Play Report, March 2024 – World

Attachments

Author: Philip James, Kate Sadler, Amir Samnani and Emily Mates

Executive summary

Introduction

In recent years there has been significant global momentum on progressing women’s and adolescent girls’ nutrition. Daily multiple micronutrient supplements (MMS), received through antenatal care (ANC) platforms, have received particular attention. The growing evidence base describing the effectiveness of MMS for birth and maternal outcomes, together with an increasing volume of documented learning about operational aspects from several implementation research pilots, and a strongly supportive advocacy agenda, means that our understanding of the potential impacts of MMS when taken to scale is rapidly improving.

lean body tonic image

Women and girls are disproportionately affected by conflict and disasters due to their increased nutritional needs and vulnerabilities. However, there is limited consolidated information on the extent to which women and adolescent girls receive MMS in humanitarian emergencies. Where MMS programming exists in these contexts, details on implementation and barriers to successful scale-up are often lacking. This report aims to fill some of these important knowledge gaps, while recognising that this is simply a starting point for ongoing knowledge sharing and informed action.

Methods

Information for this report was sourced from a survey, two in-depth country case studies, and additional key informant interviews.

• An online survey was conducted in countries experiencing humanitarian emergencies in June 2023, addressing MMS provision, barriers and opportunities.

• Pakistan and Somalia were chosen as case studies from contrasting regional contexts. In the report we summarise the main findings from these case studies but we direct readers to the accompanying individual case study reports that contain full details (Somalia and Pakistan).

• To broaden insights into MMS programming, additional key informant interviews were conducted, including with stakeholders providing iron-folic acid (IFA) but not MMS. These interviews covered diverse humanitarian contexts, including refugee responses, conflicts, economic crises, and natural disasters.

Background

MMS

MMS are formulated to contribute towards the Recommended Dietary Allowance of 15 micronutrients for pregnant women. The formula recommended for use, and which therefore forms much of the evidence base, is the United Nations International Multiple Micronutrient Antenatal Preparation (UNIMMAP). When compared to IFA, MMS reduces low birthweight by 15%, stillbirth by 9%, preterm birth by 4%, and small-for-gestationalage deliveries by 7%. Compared to iron with or without folic acid MMS has similar benefits for preventing maternal anaemia. The 2023 Copenhagen Consensus Report underscores the considerable economic advantages of replacing IFA with MMS, estimating a return on investment of USD 37 for every USD 1 spent.

Current policy and guidance for MMS

In 2007, the World Health Organization (WHO), the World Food Programme (WFP) and the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) issued a joint statement on preventing and controlling micronutrient deficiencies in populations affected by an emergency, including recommendations on the use of daily MMS for pregnant and breastfeeding women. Since the 2007 joint statement, the recommendations have been implemented to varying degrees around the world.

Survey results: use of MMS in humanitarian emergencies

An online survey was sent to respondents from 46 eligible countries 1 in June 2023. A total of 131 individual responses were recorded, from 39 different countries. Most of the responses came from individuals working for non-governmental organisations (NGOs) (63%), followed by individuals in UNICEF country offices (24%), governments (5%) and others (8%). Respondents from 28 countries stated they distributed MMS to women in humanitarian programmes. Of the 11 countries that indicated there was no MMS provision, respondents from seven countries reported plans to implement MMS programming in the next year.

In most countries (27 out of 28), all respondents stated that under humanitarian programmes MMS was given to pregnant women. Twenty of these countries also had respondents who said that MMS was given to breastfeeding women, with a minority giving MMS to non-pregnant women (six countries) and non-pregnant adolescent girls (nine countries).

Financing of MMS programming was the most commonly reported barrier across countries, by a large margin, followed by three similarly ranked barriers: inadequate country policy/protocols, inadequate supply chain, and inadequate awareness of benefits of MMS by healthcare workers and target populations.

Summary of key findings

The key findings from the survey, case studies and additional key informant interviews are compiled and summarised here by WHO health system building block. While all of the barriers identified here were described by key informants in the context of humanitarian emergencies, they are not necessarily exclusive to these settings but rather reflect recurring themes found across the spectrum of humanitarian and development contexts.

Building block 1

Leadership and governance

MMS programming is increasingly recognised by governments as important for addressing micronutrient deficiencies among women. Support from non-government actors such as United Nations agencies, NGOs, researchers and donors with expertise in nutrition and micronutrient supplementation is often key to assisting governments to integrate MMS programming into national nutrition policy and strategy in many countries. In countries where national policies and strategies do not yet mention MMS there can be a barrier to the development of corresponding implementation guidance.

Some stakeholders view global guidance on MMS as confusing: some guidelines recommend using MMS only in ANC within the context of rigorous research, while other recommendations endorse its use in emergency settings alongside IFA. A lack of clarity in global guidance may contribute to the slow integration of MMS programming into national policy. Concerns about oversupplementation or micronutrient toxicity was reported to be a potential barrier to including MMS in national policy by a few key informants working in refugee settings where other fortified food was also made available. However, the majority of key informants stressed that these concerns are less relevant in humanitarian emergencies.

UNIMMAP MMS has been on the WHO global Essential Medicines List (EML) since 2022, which is reported to facilitate procurement, particularly in international humanitarian responses. MMS is also beginning to be integrated into national EMLs although in many countries this is still in process. There is broad understanding that this will support the scale-up of MMS through leveraging domestic resources for its purchase, by mobilising further political commitment for its integration into ANC services, and potentially reducing breaks in MMS supply chains.

Building block 2

Service delivery

Micronutrient supplementation is almost always integrated into health service provision, mainly in ANC. This is the case both in international humanitarian response and domestic crisis management. Many countries have a mixture of both IFA and MMS programming, most often with national IFA programmes and smaller-scale MMS programming at subnational level, and not yet integrated into routine government programming. Somalia and the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) are an exception: in these countries, MMS is part of the national programme. In all surveyed countries, MMS is currently provided to recipients for free during humanitarian responses, and is mainly distributed to pregnant women monthly as part of ANC.

Key barriers to scaling MMS programming in humanitarian emergencies and achieving adequate coverage of the population include limited awareness among healthcare workers and target populations, restricted access to health services, poor ANC service quality, and supply chain breaks. Key informants made a few anecdotal comments relating to fears/misconceptions among pregnant women about having larger babies due to the additional micronutrients given. Some confusion also exists at the service delivery level regarding the different uses of MMS and IFA for anaemia prevention and treatment, linked to the lack of clear guidance and challenges with health worker capacity.

Key informants described the fact that once reached through outreach and mobilisation, women are eager to participate in, and understand the value of, ANC services. Indeed, the inclusion of MMS in ANC packages reportedly encourages women to attend health facilities, anecdotally because women prefer MMS over IFA due to fewer reported side effects. There are examples, particularly from Somalia and Madagascar, of leveraging existing community health worker infrastructure to improve mobilisation and outreach for ANC.

Building block 3

Health system financing

Currently, MMS programming during humanitarian emergencies heavily relies on donors, often through non-governmental agencies like UNICEF, Vitamin Angels Alliance and other NGOs, or philanthropies such as Kirk Humanitarian. However, initiatives such as UNICEF’s Child Nutrition Fund (CNF) also aim to mobilise domestic funds for nutrition commodities, including MMS provision, in 23 countries affected by a high prevalence of child wasting. While the CNF does not have a specific funding initiative tied to humanitarian emergencies, governments that receive matching funds from the CNF could leverage these resources in crisis-affected areas of their countries.

Key informants noted that the cost of purchasing MMS is considerably higher than that related to IFA. The factors underlying this vary by country, but commonly include the additional cost of MMS, which contains 15 different micronutrients (versus only two in IFA), the need to import MMS (versus IFA, which is often locally produced) and, in some countries, an importation tax on MMS. Implementation research in countries like Pakistan and Nigeria is exploring the feasibility and cost advantages of locally producing MMS.

Some key informants from the case studies described how meeting financial requirements for programming MMS within humanitarian emergencies is challenging, explaining that there were other critical nutrition programmes, such as those treating child wasting, also remaining underfunded. Sustainable funding opportunities for MMS programming within ANC is therefore an urgent priority, recognising that this will need to part of a wider discussion on how to prioritise which interventions to fund in complex situations with constrained resources. However, opportunities are emerging in this area: key informants described the growing attention being given to the prevention of child undernutrition in humanitarian contexts by some researchers, donors and practitioners. Correspondingly, there is growing momentum and evidence generation on the role of improved maternal nutrition to reduce the risks of wasting and stunting in early childhood by reducing the prevalence of poor birth outcomes, such as low birth weight. Scaled-up MMS provision could play a vital role in prevention efforts, potentially improving funding for the product as well as improving the quality and reach of delivery platforms.

Building block 4

Health workforce

MMS is mainly delivered through ANC services, often by government health staff and occasionally by NGOs/United Nations agencies in locations with reduced government health service capacity. Health staff knowledge on MMS benefits and delivery protocols within ANC relies heavily on limited in-service training and support from NGO/ United Nations agency-funded programmes. The absence of national protocols and guidance for MMS in humanitarian programmes sometimes creates confusion around delivery protocols.

Health staff capacity challenges are common, including limited staff availability and their existing workload. Community health outreach staff, who are crucial for mobilisation and for improving MMS coverage, often face heavy workloads, making integration of MMS programming into existing work difficult, especially when remuneration is inadequate.

Enhanced in-service training, implementation guidance, and updated job descriptions can help to strengthen MMS programming, in addition to incorporating associated nutrition education and counselling within ANC. The increased focus on preventing child undernutrition in humanitarian settings, and the role maternal nutrition plays in this, offers potential opportunities to scale up support for MMS delivery through both facility-based and community-based workforces, improving ANC service provision more broadly.

Building block 5

Supplies and technology

Currently, MMS used in humanitarian programmes is imported from overseas, sourced largely through UNICEF or Kirk Humanitarian supplies and procured directly in-country by UNICEF Country Offices or NGOs such as Vitamin Angels Alliance. MMS tablets are mostly supplied in bottles of 100 or 180 tablets. Many countries adopt a protocol according to which the whole bottle is given at once, so that the desiccant inside the bottle continues to keep the tablets dry and to reduce the risk of tablets becoming discoloured over time. However, some key informants described how in order to align distribution with eight ANC contacts (i.e., monthly visits during pregnancy), sometimes the tablets from the bottles are decanted into smaller packages at facilities, adding to health staff workload.

Blister packs of 30 tablets are available but can be cost-prohibitive. While the in-country supply chain works well in some cases, such as Somalia and Sri Lanka, in other cases demand outpaces supply or supplies take time to reach programme locations. Breaks in MMS supply have occurred in several countries; these were linked to global market availability, restricted funding, and challenges with reporting and estimating need at health service level. Considerable work is being undertaken by UNICEF Supply Division and key partners, including Kirk Humanitarian and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, to develop a more reliable global supply of MMS. Key actions needed include investment to strengthen and support a network of regional producers, the adoption of a global set of common product standards, and encouraging more procurement commitments through mechanisms such as the Child Nutrition Fund.

Developing local or regional MMS production in some countries could shorten the supply chain. Establishing a buffer stock of MMS at the facility/ pharmacy level could also address unforeseen increases in demand and reporting issues within national supply chains. Finally, the inclusion of MMS on national EMLs could facilitate procurement and distribution in line with national protocols, especially in crises that are managed domestically following national protocols.

Building block 6

Information systems

Monitoring of the coverage of MMS programming is only just beginning to be integrated into national health information systems in a few humanitarian contexts, such as in Somalia.

In most places, where it exists, programme monitoring and evaluation for MMS programming relies on programme data collection and reporting, usually put in place by UNICEF, and this can be parallel to government systems. In some cases, MMS and IFA are combined into one indicator.

Since in several countries MMS is not yet written into national protocols, national-level surveys collect self-reported adherence data on iron-containing tablets/syrups for pregnant women but do not yet collect data on MMS availability and adherence. There is also a lack of data on the explanatory factors underpinning adherence to IFA or MMS.

All of this means that there are large gaps in data, and therefore in our knowledge of the availability of, and adherence to, MMS.

Given Humanitarian Response Plans (HRPs) rely first and foremost on an estimation of the number of people in need of a service or intervention, these data gaps could be a barrier to ensuring MMS programming is built into HRPs, fundraised for, and delivered.

The integration of MMS monitoring into DHIS2 in all countries where it is programmed, as well as into relevant national surveys, is important to strengthen our understanding of coverage of MMS programming. This is already beginning to happen in some places, e.g., Somalia and Pakistan, and these early experiences will contribute learning for other countries.

Conclusions

The information compiled for this report highlights a significant and growing interest in MMS programming in humanitarian emergencies, yet currently MMS programming is not being delivered at scale in these contexts. The opportunity of MMS, a much-improved product in terms of effectiveness for improving nutrition, is seen by many as a welcome opportunity to improve maternal health and pregnancy outcomes, including through the opportunity to revitalise quality ANC services more generally. However, replacing IFA with MMS cannot happen successfully without investment in overcoming many of the barriers discussed above.

While humanitarian emergencies undeniably present additional, complex barriers to MMS programming coverage, what is needed to address them in these contexts remains fundamentally the same as what is needed across all settings: namely, it entails using the lens of health systems strengthening to make MMS programming as effective as possible within quality ANC services. The opportunities this will bring are essential for the overall health and well-being of pregnant women and adolescent girls, and will help ensure we fulfil our obligations to fully support their human right to adequate nutrition.


Source link

joint genesis

Written by : Editorial team of BIPNs

Main team of content of bipns.com. Any type of content should be approved by us.

Share this article:

Leave A Comment